CC Tackles the Toilet Seat Debate. Up or Down?

It’s an age-old dispute that has lead to more breakups and divorces than cheating and erectile dysfunction combined. A minuscule fight that starts with toilet seats and ends with his inability to empathize or let her watch what she wants on TV. A territorial battle by two animals fighting for supremacy over the place where they piss. Okay, you get it. Let’s move on.

THE GIRL’S ARGUMENTS:
#1 – In the middle of the night, if not paying attention, she might fall in the toilet if the seat is up.

#2 – The toilet looks nicer when the seat is down.

#3 – How hard is it to put a seat down, really?

THE GUY’S ARGUMENTS:
#1 – A rule of thumb, look where you’re sitting in any situation. If it’s dark, turn on the lights. Guys need to sit sometimes too and they don’t fall in. Also, guys aren’t asking girls to put the seat UP so he doesn’t accidentally pee all over the seat (the very seat girls sit on!). I can’t stress this enough, check the seat position before sitting down. It’s common sense.

#2 – Nobody cares how the toilet looks.

#3 – It IS easy to put the seat down, so why can’t you do it yourself.

MY ADVICE TO GIRLS – Don’t give men the above arguments. Those arguments are stupid reasons to put the seat down and easily overturned. This is where the fight starts. Both men’s and women’s arguments are based on their own preference. Both parties are being selfish. Women, guys will get defensive especially if they feel attacked. Instead, try saying, “I’d appreciate if you could put the seat down. I know it’s silly, but could you just do it for me?”

MY ADVICE TO GUYS – Why are you arguing over this? Just put the seat down.  If you’ve learned anything in relationships, it’s as long as the lady is happy, you’re happy too. Also known as, what’s good for the goose is good for the gander. Don’t provide fuel for the flames. I have been putting seats down for many, many, many years and have never had this argument with a girlfriend (however, I will argue with other people’s girlfriends just to point out that their argument, unlike a toilet, holds no water).

THE ARGUMENT PROVIDED BY  SCIENCE – Ladies, are your men still being stubborn assholes? Here’s a real argument for you that might change his preference of seat up to seat down. Flushing the toilet with the lid up releases far more poop and peep particles into the air than flushing with the lid down. These particles land on your hand towels, face towels, shower towels and, worst of all, your toothbrush. Yum!

**EDIT** – MythBusters actually had some interesting results testing the amount of fecal coliform on toothbrushes, but they only tested this while flushing with the lid up and there were confound variables to consider. It’s hard to know what to take from their tests, except that yes, there is a tiny bit of poo on your toothbrush, but there may be a tiny bit of poo everywhere and it’s not something you need to worry about. You can find that episode of MythBusters here [9:50 running time] (hat tip to The Rabid Iguana). ***

Remember to be patient. If a man has been leaving the seat up for 20 years it’s going to a take a while to get used to putting it down. Here’s hoping this blog post saves some women from cannon-balling into the john at 4am.

Did I miss any arguments? I’d be happy to add and address anything I missed. Do you agree or disagree with my reasoning?

  • The Rabid Iguana

    Actually, MythBusters provided that putting the seat down does nothing to thwart the escape of poo particles.

    The proper response is to go prison style and just remove the seat.

    • @The Rabid Iguana – Thanks for response. I checked out the MythBusters episode (see edited post) and it was rather interesting. They actually didn’t test it with the seat down, unless I missed that part or I watched the wrong episode and there were some confound variables to consider such as the methods used to apply the toothpaste, and also the fact they did the testing for fecal coliform in the bathroom, which included bringing the control toothbrushes into the bathroom thus possibly contaminating the controls. The amount of fecal coliform found was so low I don’t think it’s something we need to think of every time we brush our teeth anyway.

  • The Rabid Iguana

    One further point: in almost all cases, where there is poo there is a seat put down.

Follow CC on ...